top of page
Search

A little something on Dialectics

Writer: Isabelle Dolis
Isabelle Dolis
1 day ago
3 min read

As we mourn the passing of one of the greats in the therapy world; the unforgettable and momentously inspiring Marsha Linehan, it seems completely appropriate to reflect on dialectics and how they are both challenging to grasp and helpful to ponder on.

Marsha Linehan trained as a psychiatrist and went on to develop Dialectical Behaviour Therapy. What perhaps is even more interesting is what preceded this. Young Marsha suffered with debilitating mental ill health and spent time in a psychiatric institution as a young woman which she described as “hell” in her memoir, a hell that she was not only intent on escaping, but also on freeing others from.


She knew intense emotional pain, the ”demons”; she felt the unrelenting urges to escape by any means even if it meant harming herself. She did also realise the uncomfortable truth that to get out of hell, she would need to “go through the fire to the other side”.


Linehan understood that what was needed was compassion, skills and tools and she created an approach that is both practical without being simplistic, engaging yet cognisant of the contradictions all minds struggle with; and she constructed an extensive therapeutic scaffold for when severe suffering claws the heart, mind and soul.


She proposed that developing moment to moment awareness of experience without immediate reaction was needed, mindfulness in short. She also realised that learning to tolerate immense distress and knowing how not to make things worse would help. Additionally, she identified that emotions needed to be better understood so they could be regulated more effectively even when their intensity felt near unbearable. Finally, she appreciated that the tricky terrain of interpersonal relationships needed attention and designed tools that would help communicate needs effectively and develop boundaries and self-respect.


At the core of this therapy lies the idea that opposing notions can coexist, and we can work effectively with these tensions. So, acceptance can come alongside change. People can accept themselves as they are and also work towards change as they build a life truly worth living. Choices made at a time of crisis can be validated and better options or new ways of functioning identified.


I am not a DBT practitioner, but I find dialectics a useful idea. Dialectics proposes that progression of thought comes from resolving contradictions. Two apparently opposing concepts can be true at the same time. This allows us to recognize and allow what is, whilst also imagining and working towards what can be. No ‘either, or’, no ‘yes, but’. Night can only exist if there is day and it is amazing what beauty can grow out of a stone wall with a little sun and water.


Therapy for me is of course about talking and being, yet talking alone perhaps only goes so far. When paired with well thought through practice and action, there is the possibility of change being bedded in and magnified; and that is worth having. You can talk about running all you like but unless you put the trainers on and get out, you may get what running can do, yet you cannot experience what running can do.


So, I propose we talk and think things through in therapy, we play in therapy, we act and rehearse skills and scenarios in therapy, we learn in therapy, we draw and make marks in therapy, we pause sometimes and stay silent for a bit... AND you have a go with what we’ve figured out and you do that between therapy, little by little, step by step and then you watch YOU grow.


I think it best that Linehan has the final word, so there:

“You can’t think yourself into new ways of acting; you can only act yourself into new ways of thinking.”


―Marsha M. Linehan,

 
 
bottom of page